Tuesday, 4 August 2015

Working Together

The recent approval of 41 dwellings and a doctors surgery in Husbands Bosworth by Harborough Planning Committee represents one of most satisfying professional achievements of my career.



The story started over a year ago when Davidsons Developments commissioned Landmark Planning to promote a development of 28 dwellings to the south of the village. The location was outside the village envelope with great views southwards over open countryside. 

Following extensive public consultation it became apparent that was a pressing need in the village to secure the future of the doctor's surgery, which is housed in a totally inadequate building.

Working with the community and all the other stakeholders we managed to come up with a proposal where the developers would make a very substantial contribution and build a state of the art medical facility. It involved increasing the number of houses to 41. The housing mix provided a limited affordable housing contribution in the form of two bungalows, as well as a number of starter units for either market rent or for owner occupation. The doctors also made a substantial financial contribution to secure the future of this rural surgery.


Approved Layout



Promoting this radically changed proposal through the planning application now became a pleasure. All the background work with all the stakeholders from the NHS Care Commissioning Group to the Parish Council, the planning officers and both political parties represented on the Council paid off. Absolutely no objections were received to the application, which is a pretty rare occurrence in this day and age! A win win for everyone. "Negotiation not Confrontation" the companies strap line, certainly held true on this one.

Now the challenge comes in getting the S106 signed as soon as possible.  Then a detailed application can be submitted so work on site can actually begin. I cant wait to see the end result.

Peter Wilkinson

Wednesday, 8 July 2015

Jam Tomorrow

Everybody in the industry knows that we are not building enough homes and most commentators will accept that this is for a myriad of reasons: from mortgage availability to actual capacity in the industry. Many will state that the Planning system is at least partly at fault for not approving sufficient building plots in the right locations.


A current greenfield scheme in Aslockton Notts.



A recent scheme in Melbourne Derbyshire


Within the planning profession  there is considerable confusion on how you measure housing land supply availability. Published articles (e.g.research by Indigo Planning in 19th June edition of "Planning") considered that many Councils in South-East England seriously over estimated their 5 year land supply position. This was put down to differing interpretations from the "National Planning Practice Guidance" (NPPG) on whether the "Liverpool" or "Sedgefield" methods were appropriate and equally whether a 5% or 20% buffer for previous under-delivery was correct. 

Essentially the "Liverpool" method states that any housing shortfall should be evened out over the whole of the remaining Plan period, typically 15 years; while "Sedgefield" says the shortfall must be resolved in the next five years. The latter is much more in the spirit of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF): "To boost significantly the supply of housing" as encouraged in para. 47.

However, for me the reality is much more invidious, as there is a third method. I call it the "housing trajectory" one.

Take two Core Strategies recently adopted in West Northants and Rushcliffe, Notts in December 2014. In the former the approved housing trajectory in Daventry District proposes sites for only 400 homes in 2014/5, but by 2019/20 this rises to 1020 plots. Meanwhile in Rushcliffe the figure for 2015/16 is only 408, but for the five years 2018 to 2023 exceeds 1000 for each year. This helps your current 5 year land supply evaluation considerably as there is a much lower target now! The actual demand calculations are based upon the same requirement each year, but the supply is varied by being back loaded in these areas.


This back loading may be for perfectly legitimate reasons; most notably the desire to create large urban extensions; but let us not kid ourselves that in the interim we are attempting "to boost significantly the supply of housing." We are doing the opposite.

The issues involved in the supply of housing are much more complex than arguing over how to measure the supply of land. However, it would certainly help if the NPPG could provide a clearer steer on what I would say are the three, not two, methods of housing supply calculation: "Liverpool", "Sedgefield" and "Housing Trajectory". And it would also help avoid substantial repetitive debate at many planning appeals.

Peter Wilkinson

Tuesday, 16 June 2015

The Productivity Puzzle

"The headline feature in the June edition of "Business Network magazine* is the "Productivity Puzzle".

The essential thrust of the article is that the improvement of productivity in the UK over time and indeed within the East Midlands has lagged behind our international counterparts, particularly most of the G7 countries. And this clearly impacts on our ability to improve our GDP and hence enhance the living conditions of our citizens.

A number of commentators are cited who offer a variety of reasons for this tardy performance. The first "most obvious" reason is declared by Patrick Keen of Enscite is  the need to improve the skills of the workforce and "widen the talent pool of young people coming into engineering." I can readily comprehend this and indeed Landmark Planning's current most important and largest project, the Skills Hub proposal for Nottingham City Council, New and Central Colleges on land to the east of the Broadmarsh Centre in the City Centre, is trying to address this issue in Nottinghamshire.

Mark Carney, Governor of the Bank of England considers up-skillling workers is key. The recent rapid growth in the size of the workforce may have helped subdue wages growth with a disproportionate number of low skilled jobs . And this is a cyclical phenomenon that weighs on productivity. People new to jobs "are not as productive as they are with time." Again I can readily relate to this from personal experience – with the labour force growth greater in the UK than elsewhere.

George Cowcher, East Midlands Chamber of Commerce Chief Executive further points to weak business investment in recent years that has had an impact on productivity. Again a plausible partial explanation, as I know we (at Landmark Planning) have certainly been very wary of significant such investment for a number of years now, albeit we have changed our viewpoint in the last 9 months.

But then the article concentrates on the devolution debate. It argues that much greater meaningful devolution to "City Regions" could bring greater efficiencies, more accountability and better results. And certainly again you can see the possibilities of for example being able to focus investment in key sectors identified locally (for example food manufacture in Leicestershire) or direct investment and operations in areas such as public transport. I do worry that this might lead to  larger bureaucracies debating and then controlling possible expenditure. Any intervention needs to be as light touch as possible. On this issue Landmark Planning are helping organise a Royal Town Planning Institute debate with key regional opinion formers on this very topic on 4th December in Leicester, to which all are welcome. (further details to be announced).

So a wide range of variables to improve our economic performance. To this I would add the following:

No mention of how we seem to have voluminous rules and regulations, which hold back certainly small business owners who have been a major source of UK growth for many years. Here I don’t just mean European influences such as public procurement rules, but national and indeed those imposed by large firms on small when tendering for contracts. Pre tendering requirements seem to mushroom like topsy, but in my opinion do not properly assess the capability to actually do the job. As a small business owner we cannot carry all the specific expertises, but we do meet all our legal requirements from pensions to health and safety. That should be taken as a given until proved otherwise. We don’t want a nanny state or even the big boys tell the small boys how to do it. Going through all the hoops to satisfy the different administration formats wastes much non programmed time which should be the most creative of the key personnel in any firm. And that has to be a drag on productivity.

However, what I would really like to see is some proper scientific analysis of the impact of all the different influences on productivity. The relative importance of the different factors listed above and indeed others. It would be a hard job, but could well be worth the analysis. At the moment we have lots of opinions, but no real comparative substance to the arguments – it is all just a matter of opinion.

And what is yours?

*Business Network is the monthly magazine of the East Midlands Chamber of Commerce; the second largest Chamber of Commerce in the country.

Friday, 1 May 2015

Redevelopment of New Walk Centre, Leicester.


The site was the home of Leicester City Council for just under 40 years since it was first occupied. Originally built as a speculative office block it was bought new and completed from a private developer. Unfortunately it was not built to high standards and indeed construction elements were skimped, such that the block was gradually becoming not only unfit for purpose but unsafe. The Council finally moved out last year and earlier this year the buildings were demolished (see http://www.leicester.gov.uk/your-council/policies-plans-and-strategies/planning-and-development/new-walk-centre-redevelopment for live footage of the controlled explosion that finally brought this era of civic government in the City to an end).



So the Council has decanted to a variety of buildings around the City, most notably City Hall in Charles Street. The former Municipal Offices, but not used for this purpose for many years. They have been lovingly restored to a very high standard, for which the Council should be congratulated.

However, it still leaves the question what to do with this very important opportunity site in the centre of the City. 

The Friends of New Walk Charity* have taken a keen interest in the redevelopment of this important site. As Vice Chair of the Charity I was asked to form a sub committee of experienced property professionals to suggest the key criteria for judging any scheme that will be proposed for the site. Below are the results of that analysis that was presented to the candidates in the Mayoral election for Leicester in May.
The Friends of New Walk issued a challenge to all the candidates.  
Will you sign up to this 10 point plan to see the development of the New Walk Centre site for the greater good of the City? 

  1. Create an attractive space within the development that allows some of the fine buildings surrounding the site to be properly enjoyed.
  2. Maximum development height of 6/7 stories, but whatever is achieved, needs to have a 'human' scale.
  3. Mixed Use development required with substantial employment created.
  4. As much active frontages as possible to be secured, especially to the open space.
  5. Protect open space from the traffic noise and disturbance to the west (Welford Road).
  6. An emphasis in the palette of materials and colours for the site of masonry and 'Leicester red'.
  7. Protect the view in both directions from Pocklingtons Walk to New Walk.
  8. Encourage movement to and from New Walk along King Street to Market Street; with the surface of King Street being properly pedestrianised post development.
  9. A clear strategy for public transport (buses and taxis) in the area that encourages their use.
  10. Public art is required for the site. Two suggestions are the relocation of the John Biggs statue or the"Writers Block" recently approved on De Montfort Square.

*http://friendsofnewwalk.com/ For more information on the web site.

“Friends of New Walk Charitable Trust is a Charitable Trust registered at the Charity Commission under Registered Charity Number 1077476 and set up in 1994. Its objects are to promote conservation, protection and improvement of the physical and natural environment in the New Walk Conservation Area in the City of Leicester for the public benefit and for exclusively charitable purposes in accordance with the laws of England and Wales. In recent years it has done this in close co-ordination with the Leicestershire Constabulary, Leicester City Council and the City Mayor’s Office, as appropriate, by relevant lobbying and awareness-raising. Most importantly it has promoted Public Art on and in the immediate vicinity of New Walk by facilitating and funding and commissioning the erection of three representational sculptural pieces, such as the Clicker, and by appropriate encouragement of the arts on New Walk, for example by supporting the Leicester International Music Festival and offering liaison concerning certain art installations and exhibitions at New Walk Museum and Art Gallery. The Trustees also produce a Newsletter and are currently working on the production of a Video to promote New Walk, which is being shot at the moment.

Thursday, 2 April 2015

Richard III Rides Again: A postscript.



Last week saw the reburial of Richard III in Leicester. I am sure we can all think how the event could have made even better. In a different life I used to organize major City centre events. I would have had a larger procession and encouraged Channel 4 to take better camera positions (or moved the procession) to show the City off better. But if I had been organising it I would have doubtless got something else not quite right. The bottom line is that it was brilliant for the City in a multiplicity of ways. End of story.



And to be honest the same applies to current Leicester City Centre planning. For example, I would have designed Jubilee Square differently by enclosing the western side of the space to create a much better sense of enclosure and block the unattractive views of the multi-storey car park and the student flats to the west.

But overall again the public sector is doing very well in the City.

I do a significant amount of work in Nottingham. In many ways the, at times, poor relation of Leicester is stealing a march on the City of Robin Hood. At times to me there appears is a paralysis of action there.  This extends from the many times delayed new tram lines to shopping centres that are not a patch on the Highcross in Leicester, as well as possibly there being more large vacant sites near the centre. 

What Leicester needs most is the private sector to follow the public sector lead in the way it has done in the Cultural Quarter with schemes such as the Athena, the redevelopment of the Charles Street Police Headquarters (now known as Colton Square) and now the rapid occupation of the "Blue Tower," near the railway station, for a wide variety of compatible uses.
 
The successful Colton Square development
There are calls by some in Leicester’s private sector for more help and financial incentives from the Council. This ranges from making car access easier, more car parking and enterprise zones to business incentives. In my opinion this is wrong. Leicester has its act together in a way that puts competing cities to shame. And others should get on the bandwagon, as IBM have with a major new investment in the City centre. Developers should do this before property prices rise substantially.

The property cycle is in the best position for years for successful development. Don’t miss out.


Peter Wilkinson

Tuesday, 17 March 2015

Planning and Health


In recent times there has been much hand wringing about the state of the nations's health. More sedentary life styles and increased affluence has helped fuel what many perceive as an explosion in obesity. There has even been talk that the average age at death statistics that have been rising for well over 100 years, may start turning in the other direction. Either way the burden on the NHS is expected to grow and grow.



Planning and public health has had a sometimes curious relationship.

The development of  planning system in the U.K. was inextricably linked with public health. Much of the inspiration for the development of town planning in the second half of the nineteenth century focussed on the need to improve health and living conditions in the rapidly expanding urban centres of the 'workshop of the world.' The promoter of the first Act of Parliament to include town planning (Housing and Town Planning Act 1909) stated that the purpose was to provide conditions where firstly the physical health of the population can be improved. 

A century on, planning for health remains a core objective for most current Local Plans. For example, the recently adopted Rushcliffe Core Strategy includes, as one of its key objectives: "Health and well-being: to create the conditions for a healthier population by addressing environmental factors underpinning health and wellbeing……

However, as a Planner, I am sure I am not alone in wondering what exactly can we do to properly improve the health of the nation. Sure, I can occasionally see a head line grabbing decision: like limiting the opening of one individual kebab shop near a school. But it hardly amounts to a coherent strategy.

The separation of the two professions of planning and health care has been immense. 

In my view most decisions of spatial significance in the health care arena have been taken by a nationally constructed body (the NHS), which focusses on curing ill health. The plaudits go to the inventors of a new response to a health problem. In comparison, little recognition or resources go into promoting better health in the NHS.

Planning has focussed on the controlling of development. Development Management as we now call it. There is limited vision in building new communities: as in the heady days of post the 2WW with over 20 new towns designated under the New Towns Act of 1946.

But the issue of the nexus of planning and health is at least rising up the agenda. The NHS is beginning to shift at least some focus onto promoting good health to prevent disease and ill health. At the same time some Planners, frustrated at being development controllers, are looking to be more innovative and forward thinking.

This separation of professions into different separate silos is symptomatic of most professions. To at least attempt to start addressing this problem for complex spatial challenges in the built environment various professionals have come together to hold a series of occasional free seminars in the early evening in Leicester. For the fourth in the series the Landscape Institute, the RTPI and RICS have combined to consider: "Planning to get better: Healthy Places and the NHS Liveability Agenda"

Please join us at a free seminar on 20th April at 5.30pm in a pub at the "Parcel Yard" next to Leicester railway station. For further details see the conference section of this web site.

Peter Wilkinson


Thursday, 22 January 2015

The World has moved on: New is Good

I was recently asked to give a talk by Vince Cable's  Department for Business, Innovation & Skills (BIS) to public sector staff involved in development management on how they could work better with private sector.

A poisoned chalice if ever I saw one! But always loving the sound of my own voice I said I would give it a go. Now the event was cancelled in the end, but as I had put my talk structure already I might as well use it in a blog.

The first point I wanted to make was a philosophical or attitude one.

New development should be considered good. The dramatic improvements in the quality of construction and with it sustainability in the last 40 years means that the use of the old is generally inefficient and resource hungry. It is usually contrary to the good stewardship of the planet. How much warmer our houses are compared with only 20 years ago? The default position should be support for any proposal unless proved otherwise.

Who would chose the technology of the 60's over today's standards?

The second was how complex, long winded and expensive is the development process. As planners we are only involved in a limited part of the process: a sixth at best. The developer has to be a person of real resource who can manage the complexity. S(he) should be helped over the line because as a society we need these people of vision; expertise; stamina; and, endurance. 

To give my talk an edge I undertook a straw poll of roughly the largest 11 planning practices in the East Midlands of their main gripes on how the system is administered in the region. Six replied. There were also 6 areas for improvement, which received more than one vote.
  • Tick boxing
  • Failure to put consultee comments on public access pages (causes delays chasing comments).
  • Website not user friendly; very difficult to do planning history searches.
  • Not returning or not responding quickly to phone calls, e-mails and letters.
  • Delays and O’ Level standard of response to pre-application advice.
  • Delays receiving statutory consulters responses.  Not making helpful suggestions, as per NPPF Para 186 &187.
I had structured my talk to allow the audience to give their criticism the other way of the private sector. That might have been illuminating as well!

And as for solutions to the above we will have to wait for another day and another blog.

Peter Wilkinson